Understanding dementia home care in India

Almost one year ago, a very dedicated volunteer told me that though she tries her best to help home caregivers, she sometimes wonders whether she can ever understand them enough to help them. She had been facing problems with staff who would not understand what dementia was, and would quit at the smallest “difficult behavior”, and there were days she felt driven up a wall herself. She just couldn’t imagine living with and coping with a patient all the time, the way family caregivers did.

This volunteer told me that while she gave family caregivers what she felt was appropriate advice and hoped it helped, she felt diffident about it at times.

Being both a caregiver and a volunteer, I am often able to connect with the situation and challenges of home care, because even if I have not faced some of the problems others talk about (and boy, there is a wide range of problems out there), I can extend my experience to imagine it. This volunteer’s comment made me realize that perhaps I should do something about this gap of understanding that non-caregiver volunteers experience. I also realized that when some volunteers ended up sounding preachy, insensitive or critical, they may just be naïve and ignorant.

Anyone who has brought up kids would know the difference between handling a child 24 hours, through illness and tantrums and soiled clothes, as against playing with them or babysitting them for a few hours in a neighbor’s house. Things always look different in short, controlled situations from which one can opt out.

Most volunteers who advise home caregivers have never worked as attendants/ caregivers in a respite care on a 24 hour shift for a few days consecutively… Most have never had to stay awake day and night and clean a soiled person who is pushing them away and shouting at them in the middle of the night…(maybe volunteers should go through such experiences, though, it would make them so much more effective as advisors)

Anyway, prompted by the comment of the above-quoted volunteer, I wrote a short note to describe what dementia home care involves (my original draft was five times this length, but I reduced it to keep it at a readable length). I think anyone in contact with home caregivers may find it useful to get some idea of what caregivers are experiencing.

The note was featured by Hendi Lingiah on her blog at (http://alzheimerdiseaseinindia.blogspot.com (thanks, Hendi!), but her blog has a different readership from mine, so I am including the note in its entirety here (You can also download it as a PDF here)

Dementia Home Care: Context and Challenges in India

by Swapna Kishore

Family caregivers of persons with dementia (India) cope with extremely stressful situations and need support from people and systems around them. This note provides an introduction to dementia home care in India, a country where awareness is low, dementia is often confused with old age, diagnosis is delayed, support systems are pathetic, and where the society expects a lot from caregivers under the umbrella of duty, love, joint family, and culture, but does not know enough about dementia to effectively support families in such care.

Given the poor awareness and delayed diagnosis, families become caregivers before receiving any diagnosis; caregivers don’t know that the patient’s difficult behaviour is caused by a medical condition, and are not aware of appropriate techniques to handle the situation.

Poor knowledge about dementia means that much of the behaviour caused by dementia is seen as intentional and hurtful, and family members feel betrayed and bewildered, and often respond in ways that worsen the situation. Even professionals like surgeons and doctors prefer not to treat their own family members, and they acknowledge that it is difficult to remain dispassionate and objective when dealing with persons one is emotionally close to. Family caregivers (uninformed about dementia’s impact on behaviour) are often upset or disheartened by the accusations flung by deluded patients, or when loved ones lose their memories and fail to recognize them.

Family members are thrust into the caregiver role because they need to do it. It is not their chosen vocation, nor are they trained for it. They squeeze the time, energy and money needed for this role along with other, equally important roles, like being parents, spouse, handling other elders and ailing persons, along with their own careers. Balancing multiple roles takes a toll on the entire family. Children may require support because they are preparing for important exams. They may require attention because they are being influenced by undesirable friends. A family member may fall ill, say, get cancer or a heart attack, or be injured in an accident. Because all these have to be handled along with care of a person with dementia, life is an endless struggle to fit in everything. Even a day’s break is often infeasible. Dementia care is not a short-term adjustment of a few weeks or months–it extends for years.

Because caregiving requires time and energy, caregivers often give up jobs or switch to part-time work (thus giving up income sources) while spending more money in care (increasing expenses). Every adjustment required for the comfort and care of the patient costs time and money, which means sacrificing something else, like foregoing tuition for a child, or a medical check-up for another family member, or reducing nutritious food. But many caregivers, feeling a sense of shame, do not talk of their financial problems.

Dementia awareness is very poor in India. People often criticize families based on deluded complaints of patients, or because of their own ideas of what care should be—this is based on what normal elders want, though it may be unsuitable for someone suffering from dementia. For example, relatives and neighbours may call family members cruel if they keep doors locked to prevent wandering. Or they may insist that families show “respect” for the patient by letting the patients take major financial and other decisions that they are no longer capable of making. Criticism sometimes reaches extremes like accusations of neglect or theft or attempted murder and people even threaten to inform the police. Caregivers have to cope with these in addition to trying to care for the patient.

The emotional cost of caregiving is particularly severe on close family members, because they feel involved with the patient. Seeing someone you love lose their memories is stressful, especially when the patient stops recognizing family members. Seeing them become increasingly dependent is also very distressing. And knowing that there is no cure makes it worse. Many caregivers who are blood-relatives of the patient have the additional stress that they too are at risk of developing dementia. As caregiving for the patient extends across years, sometimes more than a decade, all these combine to create a continued high-stress situation. Caregiving also occupies so much time and energy that the death of the patient leaves an unbearable vacuum and results in a loss of identity for the caregiver.

India’s cultural environment equates care of dementia patients with the “joint family” system where people live with ageing elders. Caregivers are often bombarded with lectures on how they must “love” their parents, how elder care is “normal” and “duty”, and how it is part of being “grateful” to parents. People are always advising them on what more should be done for the ailing parent, and get upset when their advice is not followed. Caregivers hesitate to mention their fatigue, sense of overwhelm, or financial difficulties in such an environment. Caregivers spend years of intense sacrifices in the relentless caregiving that a person with dementia requires; this is accompanied with extreme isolation as they spend more and more time providing care and cannot talk about their own burnout without hearing lectures on love and duty. Even for the lucky few who are in supportive environments, advice given by others is not always appropriate because very few people try to understand what would really help before offering advice.

Volunteers and other professionals are not always tuned to the realities of dementia home care. The solutions applicable in an institutional care environment are not directly transferable to a home care environment.

For example, it is often expensive (and even infeasible) to modify homes and make them suitable for patients. Having a full-time attendant in an apartment, sharing kitchen and toilets, is difficult to adjust to, and privacy is affected. There are security risks too.

Another example: In an institutional care setting, a team of professionals provides a collection of diverse skills to cater to the needs of the patients–the dietician, the physiotherapist, the occupational therapist, the cook, the attendant, the psychiatrist, and the volunteer who comes for “activities”. At home, all this work is handled by the primary caregiver and a few others, all untrained, and all doing this in addition to multiple other roles. Yet these required skills are not instinctive, otherwise the “professionals” would not need years of training, observation, supervision and practice.

Being relaxed and calm while coping with a person with dementia is easier in institutional care, where handling a patient is part of a well-defined job. The home care setting is different; here, the caregiver is often sleep-backlogged and also emotionally stressed by seeing a loved one’s strange behaviour. It is inhuman to expect a family caregiver to always be patient in such a case. Also, family caregivers do not always have the time. For example, a family caregiver who has to leave the patient at a day care and then go for an important meeting is likely to get restless if the patient is just not cooperating to get ready. The aspect of juggling multiple roles is often missed out by persons who only consider one aspect of the caregiver’s life–the role in dementia care–and forget all other things this person is balancing all the time. A volunteer can take a day off for a personal emergency, but a family caregiver juggles other emergencies with dementia care. Even if unwell, the family caregiver still has to do what is needed for the patient at home. This is tremendously taxing physically and emotionally.

Dementia home care has been likened to a 36-hour day, and what is remarkable is that in spite of all these problems, most families adjust their lives and provide reasonable care for the patients. Yet family caregivers clearly need help. This note is an attempt to provide a flavour of home care realities so that concerned persons can provide suitable help and suggestions, while remaining sensitive and respectful of what families achieve in face of so many challenges.

(Download as PDF here: Dementia Home Care: Context and Challenges in India)

(As understanding the realities of dementia home care in India are very relevant for persons who may want to support caregivers, I have also made this document available in Slideshare and included it on this blog in my section Resources for volunteers, as a page Introduction: dementia home care in India.)

If you like this post, please Share/ like this post using the buttons below.

You can also follow this blog by getting email notifications; click the “Follow me” option at the bottom of the right sidebar. Thank you!

About Swapna Kishore
I'm a writer, blogger, and resource person for dementia/ caregiving in India. I have also been a dementia caregiver for well over a decade, and am deeply concerned about dementia care in India; on this blog I share my personal caregiving journey, my experiences as a resource person for dementia care, and musings on life, aging, dementia in India, and such sundries. More about me and the work I do for dementia care. For structured information on dementia, for discussions, tools and tips on caregiving issues, for resources in India, and for caregiver interviews, please check my website http://dementiacarenotes.in (or its Hindi version, http://dementiahindi.com). For videos on dementia caregiving (English and Hindi), check the youtube channel here.

2 Responses to Understanding dementia home care in India

  1. Supriya dutt says:

    Swapna, everything you write is so true and we must try to get a caregiver group in each city. If you want to invite caregivers in other cities I’d be happy to help for Delhi/ Gurgaon.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s